Six Mortgage Myths That Can Cost You Money

Do you believe that you can't borrow money to buy a house if you have some dings on your credit? Do you think it's always best to pay off the mortgage early, if you can? If so, you subscribe to mortgage myths that can cost you money. Here are six common myths.

Myth 1: A 30-year fixed is always the best way to go.  

Adjustable-rate mortgages, or ARMs, constitute one-third of home loans these days. Yet rates on 15- and 30-year fixed-rate mortgages are very low by historical standards. ARM rates are even lower, but they could rise when it's time for them to adjust.

You're going to hear a lot of financial journalists who say these ARMs are dangerous, you're putting your house at risk, you're crazy to take an ARM at this time of historic lows. It's true, that a long-term, fixed-rate mortgage is the right loan if somebody says, “I'm going to be in that house forever.” That's an automatic 30-year fixed.

But the average homeowner stays in the house about nine years. First-time home buyers, who usually are young and have expanding families and growing incomes, are likely to remain in their starter homes for just a few years before moving on and up.

Adjustables, especially the popular hybrid adjustables that carry an introductory rate that lasts three, five, seven or 10 years, are appropriate for those whom Walters calls "upwardly mobile people, people who are transient, people for whom a payment increase wouldn't be the end of the world."

Myth 2: Pay off that mortgage as soon as possible.  

Accelerating mortgage payments is another area where emotion can often trump reason.  This is where finances and psychology meet.

Imagine a scenario where you have a 5- percent ARM and are able to deduct the interest from your federal income taxes. That lowers the effective interest rate to somewhere in the neighborhood of 3.75 percent. Instead of paying extra principal on such a mortgage, it may make more sense to pay down higher-interest debt, such as for credit cards and auto loans, or to invest the money where it can earn a return greater than the mortgage interest rate after taxes. The way people deal with money and risk is often irrational, and they put much more of a premium on security and safety than they do on getting a return.

It's perfectly fine to pay off a mortgage early if doing so satisfies a long-term financial goal. A lot of aging baby boomers want to eliminate their mortgage debt so they can retire debt-free. That makes sense, especially for retirees who won't exceed the standard deduction on their income taxes and therefore won't be able to deduct their mortgage interest. That goal, however, can be achieved in more effective ways other that accelerated mortgage payments.

Myth 3: You need a down payment of 20 percent or at least 10 percent.  

The perception out there -- that you need 10 percent down at least, maybe 20 -- that's completely incorrect. Many lenders have lots of loan programs for people who can afford to pay 5 percent down or less including zero down. In the mortgage industry's horse-and-buggy days, the only zero-down loan was available from the Veterans Administration. That's no longer the case.

A lot of people are caught in a cycle where they're paying a lot every month for rent and are paying bills on time, and they don't have a lot of money to save. They think they're trapped in the renting cycle with no way out, but they have several options. That takes us to the next myth.

Myth 4: You have to pay mortgage insurance if you don't have enough money for a 20 percent down payment.  

What's called “piggyback financing” is now almost 50 percent of home purchases. A piggyback loan lets you avoid paying for mortgage insurance.

Piggyback financing consists of two loans. The first is for 80 percent of the purchase price. Then there's a second "piggyback" loan for the rest of the purchase price, minus the down payment. An 80-10-10 mortgage has a 10 percent down payment and a 10 percent piggyback loan; an 80-15-5 has a 5 percent down payment and a 15 percent piggyback loan; and an 80-20 doesn't have a down payment at all.

The piggyback loan has a higher rate than the primary mortgage for 80 percent of the price. But for people with good credit, piggyback financing usually costs less than getting one mortgage for more than 80 percent of the price and then paying for mortgage insurance.

These are favorable loans because one, they can maximize the house that they can buy, but two, they also maximize the tax deduction. That's because the mortgage interest on the piggyback loan is tax deductible, whereas mortgage insurance premiums are not. (An attempt this year to extend the tax deduction to mortgage insurance failed in Congress.)

There are two reasons why some lenders would push people to take PMI, private mortgage insurance. The first reason is that the lender doesn't offer piggyback loan programs, so limited options make for clear choices. Other lenders have investments in mortgage insurance companies, so they profit from increased business, he says.

Myth 5: You can't get a mortgage if you have blemishes on your credit.  

More and more lenders are finding ways to lend to people with flawed credit histories. The word "subprime" is used to describe loans to people who have credit problems that are serious enough to justify charging higher rates. The lender demands a higher rate to compensate for the higher risk. About one-third of households fall into the subprime category.

One or two 30-day-late credit card payments won't push you into subprime territory, but bankruptcy, foreclosure, repossession, a habit of paying bills late, and even eviction from an apartment can turn you into a subprime customer. A short, sparse credit history, a recent immigrant or a college graduate might be counted as subprime, too.

A word of advice to those who feel their credit could be considered subprime is to work with a lender that does prime and subprime loans: You're less likely to be steered into a mortgage with a higher rate than you deserve to pay.

If you do fall into a subprime loan, all is not lost because these are usually (or should be) temporary solutions. Make sure your lender can help you track the subprime loan and design a strategy to refinance when you become eligible to qualify for a conforming loan.
 

Myth 6: The term of the mortgage has to be the term on the note.  

Lots of borrowers are reluctant to refinance because they don't want to start all over again with a new loan that's due to be paid off in 15 or 30 years. But you can ask the lender to set you up with a shorter payment schedule.

Take the example of someone who got a 30-year mortgage in 1998 and wants to refinance in 2004 at a lower rate. It's a simple matter to ask the lender to amortize the payments so the new loan will be paid off in 2028, when the original loan would have been retired. Your payment will be lower than it was before, and you'll save monthly -- and over the same period of time.